A layperson’s guide to historic commercial building styles in Wisconsin

A layperson’s guide to historic commercial building styles in Wisconsin

2018-01-11T21:39:56+00:00January 11, 2018|Places, Preservation|

Written by Joe Lawniczak, Wisconsin Main Street | Edited by Jim Draeger, Wisconsin Historical Society

If you’re like most people, being able to identify a building’s architectural style is about the same as being able to recognize whether your favorite song is in 2/4 time or 4/4 time. It matters little to most of us. All we know is we like certain songs and not others. Similarly, most of us may like the way a certain historic building looks, but very few of us care how the slight nuances in the size, shape or location of its elements can define it as one style or another.

But even if we don’t have a desire to learn all about the various types of historic buildings, it is still important that architectural surveys are done to help us identify the structures in our districts. Knowing a building’s style is like a blueprint. It provides clues to what a building would have looked like originally, especially if it has undergone changes in the past. Knowing a building’s style can help to determine roughly when it was built, and conversely, knowing when it was built can sometimes help us determine what style it is/was and what window styles and storefront designs are appropriate.

If we strive to respect our local heritage, then our historic buildings are vital in helping us understand the people, times, fashions, lifestyles, technologies, and industries that existed before us, and how they shaped our communities, regions, and state.

But if you’ve ever read books or researched online about building styles, you’ve no doubt found that most of the examples they show are of historic homes, not commercial structures. This can make it very difficult for the average person to make a determination about a Main Street building’s style. Also, most books or online guides show only one or two examples for each style, despite the fact that most styles have numerous variations.

Furthermore, some buildings defy categorization, so preservation consultants must guess, or lump them into what I call “catch-all” styles, such as “Commercial Vernacular”, or the even more vague “Other Vernacular”. The problem is, there is then no one unifying characteristic of vernacular, so it’s difficult to use its classification as a blueprint for a renovation or restoration project.

But beyond building elements, European immigrants made their mark on the state, shaping the character of our communities here in Wisconsin when they arrived. Their old world knowledge and construction skills influenced their building material choices.  Miners in Mineral Point preferred the local limestone, while Germans in eastern Wisconsin built from local fieldstone.  In the Northwoods, Finns and Swedes preferred log and timber construction.  In some places, like Milwaukee, immigrants built styles popular in the homeland, such as t Flemish and German Renaissance Revival style buildings.  Most commonly, commercial architectural styles were borrowed from the dominant styles popularized in the eastern United States such as the Federal Style or the Italianate Style.

As a result, most of America’s popular building styles are represented within the state, from the more decorative Italianate and Queen Anne, to the more utilitarian twentieth century styles. Since most of the development in Wisconsin began in the mid-1840s, examples of early styles, such as Georgian, Colonial, Jeffersonian, or Dutch Colonial are not prevalent in the state. But one early style that pre-dated Wisconsin’s statehood is the Federal style, which survives mainly in historic mining towns in the southwestern part of the state, such as Mineral Point and Platteville.

A list of the major historic commercial building styles found in Wisconsin today can be found below (in order from most prevalent to least) along with multiple illustrations of each. While virtually every building style exists in the larger cities of Milwaukee and Madison, nearly all of the examples highlighted are purposely from smaller communities, both urban and rural. All photos courtesy of either the Wisconsin Historical Society Architecture and History Inventory (WHS) or Wisconsin Main Street (WiMS).

Historic commercial building styles in Wisconsin

Commercial Vernacular
Spans most eras

Very common to all areas of the state. Almost half of all retail buildings ever surveyed are lumped into this category. By definition, vernacular buildings reflected the traditions, materials, and building methods of the region they were built, thus why there is no one unifying characteristic. They generally adopted the forms, scale and materials of more high style building of their period, but lacked stylistic details.

319 Watson, Ripon (WiMS)

113 Main St., Belleville (WHS)

112 S. 3rd Ave., Sturgeon Bay (WHS)

Italianate
1840-1900

Characterized by arched or ornate windows and decorative brickwork, the Italianate was the most common 19th century style in the state. Common in every corner of Wisconsin, but very prevalent in cities such as Ripon, Watertown and Janesville.

Block in Ripon (WiMS)

Smith Building in Sheboygan Falls (WiMS)

Block in La Crosse (WHS)

False Front Commercial, also known as Boomtown
1860-1905

Characterized by tall false facades (parapets) hiding a pitched roof behind. Common in all areas of Wisconsin, especially in rural areas. These wood-framed and wood-sided buildings were typically built during a city’s first commercial boom, but were often lost to fire and replaced with brick in the late-1800s. Hundreds still survive today.

Former jewelry store, Sturgeon Bay (WiMS)

Lighting Store, Sheboygan Falls (WiMS)

Andrew Tate Building, Bayfield (WHS)

Twentieth Century Commercial
1900-1930

Typically incorporating a stepped or patterned brick or stone cornice on otherwise simple facades and often built of “wire-cut” brick. Common in Milwaukee, Madison, Fond du Lac, Burlington and Beloit.

Messe Block, Burlington (WHS)

Doran Plumbing, Waupaca (WHS)

Bagels & More, Beloit (WHS)

Queen Anne
1880-1910

Characterized by Victorian-type ornamentation, many utilizing bay windows and turrets. These uncommon buildings were more common in larger cities like Milwaukee, Janesville, Madison, Oshkosh, Racine, Burlington, Appleton, Evansville and Manitowoc.

Gund Building, La Crosse (WHS)

Snashall & Mygatt Block, Evansville (WHS)

Villager, Sheboygan Falls (WiMS)

Front Gabled
1875-1915

Front gabled buildings are similar to Boomtown in that they have pitched roofs, but instead of the gable end being concealed by a false façade (parapet), the roofline is visible. Examples of this style exist all over Wisconsin, but are predominantly found in Milwaukee and its suburbs.

Brady Street, Milwaukee

Primrose Parlor, Rice Lake (WiMS)

451 E. Main Street, Mishicot (WHS)

Neoclassical
1895-1935

This style is typically reserved for monumental buildings, such as banks and museums, with prominent columns and cornices derived from Greek and Roman architecture.  This style can readily be found in Milwaukee, Madison, La Crosse, Oshkosh, Racine, Superior and Janesville.

First National Bank, Viroqua (WiMS)

Jung Building, Sheboygan (WHS)

Upper windows in Fond du Lac (WiMS)

Romanesque Revival
1870-1900

The overriding characteristic of this style in commercial architecture are multiple windows connected under broad arches or connected in a series of arches. This building type is common in Milwaukee, Oshkosh, Superior, La Crosse, Madison, Racine and Stevens Point.

1314 3rd St., Stevens Point (WHS)

Fox Theater, Stevens Point (WHS)

Mediterranean Revival
1890-1930

Clay tile roofs or mansard canopies and/or shaped gables drawn from Spanish missions characterize this building style. Often found in suburban strips in and around Milwaukee.

1848 Fond du Lac Ave., Milwaukee (WiMS)

6528 W. North Ave., Wauwatosa (WHS)

8004 W. National Ave. West Allis

Art Deco
1925-1940

This style popularized by the Paris World’s Fair incorporates strong vertical lines, geometric machine-like ornamentation, and smooth stone or stucco exteriors. Often used for government buildings like post offices and courthouses built during the Great Depression, this style was most commonly found in larger cities such as Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Racine, Manitowoc, Neenah, Waukesha, Eau Claire and Janesville.

302 N. Franklin, Port Washington (WiMS)

Kaiser’s, Racine (WiMS)

Winnebago County Courthouse, Oshkosh (WHS)

Art Moderne
1930-1945

Inspired by the designs of planes and locomotives, this streamlined building style incorporated sleek surfaces and horizontal lines suggesting motion. In some cases, structural glass modern storefronts were added to non-art deco buildings. It is uncommon, but most often found in larger cities like Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Beloit, Eau Claire, Kenosha, Ashland and Sheboygan.

Bushel & Pecks, Beloit (WHS)

George Draeb Jewelers, Sturgeon Bay (WiMS)

Flemish/German Renaissance Revival
1895-1920

These Germanic styles incorporate tall, ornately-shaped gables, and exude an Old World character. Both were used in breweries and tied-house taverns. These styles are almost exclusively found in Milwaukee and its suburbs, with some examples in Sheboygan and Racine counties.

Kalczynski/Dziennik Building, Milwaukee (WHS)

Pollack Building, Racine (WHS)

HC Laack Block (WHS)

Greek Revival
1825-1860

This style largely consists of wood-framed, wood-sided structures, with returns at the eaves on the gable ends and Greek-inspired columns. The style was inspired by Greek temples and used heavily in areas developing around the time that Wisconsin became a state, such as Rock, Sheboygan and Racine counties. It can also be found in the southern Fox Valley.

Rochester Inn, Sheboygan Falls

Red Bell Market, East Troy (WHS)

Iowa County Courthouse, Dodgeville

Tudor Revival
1890-1920

This style is often easy to identify, because of the tell-tale Tudor wood and stucco gables in key areas of its buildings. This style is prevalent in larger cities such as Milwaukee, Green Bay and Madison and their suburban retail centers, as well as Sheboygan and the communities that surround it.

Third Street, Wausau (WiMS)

531 S. Main St., Fond du Lac (WHS)

Cafe Bavarian, Wauwatosa (WHS)

Chicago Commercial
1885-1915

This building type was used in larger cities for office buildings and departments stores, and incorporated grouped windows in rectangular bays divided by columns of terra cotta or stone. They can be found in Milwaukee, Racine, Kenosha, Green Bay, Superior, Marinette, La Crosse, Wausau and Manitowoc.

Bellin Building, Green Bay

Lauerman’s/Dunlap Square, Marinette (WHS)

Mayer-Lotz Building, Wausau (WiMS)

Prairie School
1900-1920

This style used low, horizontal forms, geometric detailing, reliefs and ornamentation drawn from stylized plant forms. Wisconsin’s own Frank Lloyd Wright, as well as Louis Sullivan of Chicago, were two of the most famous architects of this era. Commercial buildings are rare, but many Prairie School libraries can be found in Wisconsin small towns.

Public Library, Merrill (WHS)

Farmers & Merchants Bank, Columbus (WHS)

Jandrey & Co., Neenah (WHS)

Richardsonian Romanesque
1870-1895

Another building style (like Prairie School) developed by a famous architect. In this case, Boston architect H.H. Richardson blended Romanesque architecture with his trademark stone-arched openings and massively rough stone exterior. This building style is commonly used for banks and large civic buildings and found in larger cities such as Ashland, Superior and La Crosse, as well as Milwaukee and Oshkosh.

Mabel Tainter Theater, Menomonie (WHS)

Bristol Block, Ashland (WHS)

Waukesha County Courthouse, Waukesha (WHS)

Gothic Revival
1840-1880

This style came about on the tails of Greek Revival. It is most commonly used in religious buildings. Commercial examples are quite uncommon, utilizing tall, pointed windows and gables, and ornate detailing. Most examples can be found in Milwaukee, Mineral Point, Racine, Janesville, Eau Claire and Madison.

Upper windows in Beloit (WHS)

610 Broadway (demolished), Menomonie (WHS)

Noodles & Company on State Street, Madison (WiMS)

Beaux Arts
1885-1930

Similar to Neoclassical, with its use of large stone or terra cotta units and often columns, this monumental style was used in banks, civic buildings, museums, courthouses and even the Wisconsin State Capitol. Commercial buildings of this type were rare and only found in larger cities such as Milwaukee, Madison, Eau Claire, Kenosha, Manitowoc and Green Bay.

Northwestern Mutual Life, Milwaukee (WHS)

Bee Frank Building, Green Bay (WHS)

Yost’s Department Store, Madison (WHS)

Second Empire
1855-1885

Characterized by sloped mansard roofs and dormers set in the roofline. This style was found in many areas, including Milwaukee, Baraboo, Eau Claire, Janesville, Madison, Wausau and Port Washington.

Equitable Bank, Milwaukee (WHS)

Lancaster Hotel, Lancaster (WHS)

Chilla Building, Stevens Point (WHS)

Federal
1780-1820

One of the earliest styles found in Wisconsin, they typically consist of pitched side walls with one or two chimneys, and heavy rectangular stone lintels. They survive in the Southwestern part of the state in Mineral Point, Platteville and Prairie du Chien, but were once common in Milwaukee, Watertown, Port Washington and Racine.

Shake Rag Alley, Mineral  Point (WiMS)

Things of Importance, Platteville (WHS)

Sand Bar, Port Washington (WHS)

More reading